Not everything is possible. ", "The movie is saying that somehow we can all get together and, with our collective thought processes, we can influence the outcome" of physical events - be they life experiences or scientific experiments, notes Bruce Schumm, a particle physicist at the University of California at Santa Cruz. From my perspective, once you had identtified Smolins position( I gave this in previous post[Posted by sol at September 25, 2004 04:18 PM] ), then you would know he holds Einsteins, in relation to the Solvay meetings, and strings have modified what Bohr and Schrodinger were doing in developing QM. (2005)", "Cult Science Dressing Up Mysticism as Quantum Physics", "The New Age Spiritualist and the Old School Scholars", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=What_the_Bleep_Do_We_Know!%3F&oldid=1139210194, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, That the universe is best seen as constructed from thoughts and ideas rather than from. Quantum mechanics is a replacement for the phrase "anything goes." The brain wasn't born yesterday. What the Bleep!? I don't know how many times I've heard people say, "Oh, I love quantum mechanics because I'm really into meditation, or I love the spiritual benefits that it brings me." The movie features other proclaimed scientists who . But when you hear about quantum mechanics and consciousness, you should assume the author is a crackpot unless proven otherwise. Bleep raises thought-provoking questions about science and its relationship to spirituality and metaphysics. A scientist debunks the claim that water reacts to human emotions. But whenever one is dealing with highly speculative ideas that have no connection with experiment, theres a danger of becoming delusional and thinking that youre doing real science when youre not. I was expecting something pretty dumb, but am always interested to see what people think about quantum mechanics. Categories conflate, confound, connect", "Our power is in our ability to decide - Can you? In the film, during a discussion of the influence of experience on perception, Candace Pert notes a story, which she says she believes is true, of Native Americans being unable to see Columbus's ships because they were outside their experience. With Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, John Ross Bowie, Robert Bailey Jr.. A fictional photographer's quest to spiritually rediscover herself is interspersed with documentary footage of scientists and theologians discussing the philosophical aspects of quantum physics. Short Range Tests of Newtons Inverse-Square Law. log out. Often, people who are trying to sell whatever it is they're trying to sell try to justify it on the basis of science. Q. It is true that quantum mechanics is extremely strange, and on extremely small scales for short times, all sorts of weird things happen. It was clearly time to check the facts for myself. I think its a good idea for people to consider the example of Hagelin: hes completely delusional and has zero common sense, but able to function at a high level in the particle theory community. Since its release in April 2004, this independent film has become a cult hit, playing to packed houses and grossing over $7.5 . How had the discussion from WTB (What the BLEEP) moved and evolved? But how are ordinary mortals to judge its assertions about the nature of matter, mind, and the universe? But when animated, jive-talkin' human cells start dancing around in what appears to be the heroine's frontal lobe, all questions of spirituality pale before the sheer dreadfulness of this movie. Do We Know!?) I mean listen, you have very reputable individuals who believe in validation, as experimental proof. Q: Obviously, quantum mechanics has lots of real-life applications, including in your television set and your microwave oven. Wow, indeed! He claims the drop was achieved. First, such claims rely on "hidden variables" susceptible to influence, he says. Publishers Weekly What the Bleep Do We Know!? Knight's compound outside the town of Yelm has been built over the former horse-breeding grounds: The estate consists of JZ's present home, a white 12,800 square foot French chateau styled 4-bedroom house, her original home (a 1,600 sq. It is my task to convince you not to turn away because you don't understand it. Reality is happening in our brain all the time we're receiving it but it's not being integrated." Those points suggest that quantum-derived "possibilities" affect the wider world, that human thought is the ultimate arbiter of physical reality, and that by manipulating thought properly, people can achieve harmony and even shape the structure of matter. But we're certainly using them at the Large Hadron Collider, which we couldn't even operate if we didn't have superconducting magnets. And you'd do the study without knowing what had been 'said' to the water specimens, so your subjective opinions wouldn't colour the results. As long as a sub-atomic particle is interacting with another sub-atomic particle, they'll both exist regardless of where you are or what you're doing. A: Absolutely. The narrative follows a fictional photographer, Amanda, through her emotional and existential journey of life. ), is hooked on prescription pills, and mopes about while her chirpy roommate spatters paint around their apartment. At the end of this article, Dr Simons invites readers to explore the limitations of their own brains. Thanks to Pylon Sentinel for pointing this out.A link to his Wikipedia page is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Alan_Wolf 8. With researchers and theoretical scientists leading the way, it takes the reader through the looking glass of quantum physics into a universe that is more bizarre and alive than ever imagined. It went on to say that "Most laypeople cannot tell where the quantum physics ends and the quantum nonsense begins, and many are susceptible to being misguided," and that "a physics student may be unable to convincingly confront unjustified extrapolations of quantum mechanics," a shortcoming which the authors attribute to the current teaching of quantum mechanics, in which "we tacitly deny the mysteries physics has encountered". The article states that the domestic gross exceeded $10 million, described as not bad for a low-budget documentary, and that the DVD release attained even more significant success with over a million units shipped in the first six months following its release in March 2005. Has this experiment been replicated or verified? Do We Know!? Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. "If thoughts can do that to water, imagine what our thoughts can do to us" observed a fan of Dr Masaru Emoto in the movie. HCI president Peter Vegso stated that in regard to this book, "What the Bleep is the quantum leap in the New Age world," and "by marrying science and spirituality, it is the foundation of future thought."[5]. is released on Friday. "We only see what we believe is possible Native American Indians on Caribbean Islands couldn't see Columbus's ships [sitting on the horizon] because they were beyond their knowledge" Dr. Candace Pert (former scientist, current new-age guru) in What the Bleep Do We Know? What the Bleep Do We Know!? ISHEAGU MASSACRE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND: Isheagu is a town whose origin is traceable to the Eastern part of the contraption called Nigeria. ft. indoor riding arena once used for horse training which was refurbished and floored . Both are indeed mysterious, and their genuine mystery needs none of the hype with which this film relentlessly and noisily belabours us", concluding that the film is "tosh". A group of 3 Indian people claiming to be direct disciples of Maharishi Mahesh-Yogi visited our high school. Fred Alan Wolf, PhD in What the Bleep Do We Know? One has already been recognized: If we do carefully prepare quantum systems, and keep them isolated, we can perform quantum magic technologically potentially on scales that we haven't been able to do before. : Down the Rabbit Hole: Directed by William Arntz, Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente. So what constitutes quantum quackery? You might think that meant there were 18% fewer violent crimes than in the previous year, but the decrease was actually relative to his predicted increase based on some fancy statistical footwork. Daniel Monti, physician and director of the Mind-Body Medicine Program at. But I start to choke on my $8 popcorn when science is manipulated to make a cult leader's claims sound more plausible. This message will appear once per week After a lesson in quantum mechanics from a precocious kid on a . The idea that our own perceptions can't be trusted is not new, of course. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for What the Bleep Do We Know? Update: More information at the end of the video description.Comment approval now removed. The Christian Science Monitor has expired. Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Down the Rabbit Hole. A: Well, Roger Penrose has given lots of new-age crackpots ammunition by suggesting that at some fundamental scale, quantum mechanics might be relevant for consciousness. Quantum physics tells us that reality isn't fixed subatomic particles only come into existence when they are observed and 2. 2) "What the Bleep Do We Know" has sure got a lot of people talking and thinking. About. Quantum physics tells us that reality isn't fixed subatomic particles only come into existence when they are observed, 2. . The meditation may not have helped the victims of violent crime, but it did win Hagelin the 1994 Ig Nobel Peace Prize. Its true that Hagelin stopped doing physics in the mid-nineties to concentrate on his other nonsense, but I can vouch for the fact that as early as 1978-9 he was heavily involved in TM and thought it had a lot to do with QFT. That's one of the very strange properties of quantum mechanics. The film's central point--that reality is a construct of our own brains--seems rife with intriguing cinematic possibilities. The debate here is that we'll be able to use quantum mechanics to break codes, in particular to determine the big prime numbers that are at the basis of the security of your credit cards and your bank cards. It's certainly not. "They take advantage of things we don't know very well or can't test very well, then use it in an unfair way," notes Andr de Gouva, a particle physicist at Northwestern University in Evanston, Ill. But quantum mechanics, for better or worse, doesn't bring any more spiritual benefits than gravity does. Use this form to email 'What the bleep are they on about?' Columbus certainly didn't speak the language, and the locals didn't keep written records. [19], According to Margaret Wertheim, "History abounds with religious enthusiasts who have read spiritual portent into the arrangement of the planets, the vacuum of space, electromagnetic waves and the big bang. Quotes From the Movies Science Of The Mind Fifth Dimension Joe Dispenza Get What You Want Neurons Brain Spirituality The infinite info that the brain is processing every single second tells us there is more to the world then we're perceiving it. Is this a hoax to promote positivity? He claims that in over 5 hours of interviews he explained to the film makers why their concept of how Quantum Physics works has virtually no support in the scientific community. We asked some of Britain's best scientific brains to give us their verdicts, Original reporting and incisive analysis, direct from the Guardian every morning. It presents itself as the thinking rebel's alternative to Hollywood pabulum: a heady stew of drama and documentary, starring Oscar-winning actress Marlee Matlin as a Xanax-addled photographer who. That would be, very hard to quantify:). Krauss worries that a lot of people can be fooled by appeals to the admittedly weird world of quantum physics a world in which particles are said to take every possible path from point A to point B, in which the position and velocity of particles are necessarily cloaked in uncertainty, in which the mere act of observation changes the thing being observed. have described distinct assertions made as pseudoscience. Everyone knows quantum mechanics is weird, so why not use that to justify it? "Quantum physics calculates only possibilities Who/what chooses among these possibilities to bring the actual event of experience? Marlee Matlin, Barry Newman, Elaine Hendrix. Nobody does.". The observer can't be ignored." Featuring two (!) Despite his caveats, he recommends that people see the film, stating: "I hope it develops into a cult movie in the UK as it has in the US. In the late eighties I remember seeing Maharishi University preprints, perhaps about flipped SU(5). Even though there's lots of proof that the Moon landing happened, some people don't . Dr Joe Dispenza and Miceal Ledwith are both long time students and appointed teachers at Ramthas school of enlightenment (RSE). 3. Quantum physics tells us that reality isn't fixed subatomic particles only come into existence when they are observed and 2. The Effect of Meditation on Violent Crime in Washington, DC. DVD (2005) Marlee Matlin, Arntz (DIR) cert 12 at the best online prices at eBay! Prominent if you go by citations that is. It's certainly not. [5], According to the makers of the film, "Bleep" is an expurgation of "fuck". Z. Knight and heavily features commentary from 'Ramtha', an ancient Atlantian general who is apparently speaking through Knight. What the Bleep Do We Know was directed and produced by Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente and William Arntz, all of whom were students of Ramtha's School of Enlightenment. [9] In his review, Dave Kehr of The New York Times described the "transition from quantum mechanics to cognitive therapy" as "plausible", but stated also that "the subsequent leapfrom cognitive therapy into large, hazy spiritual beliefsisn't as effectively executed. You can be accurate in one or the other, but not in both. If he says hes being misrepresented, I quite believe him. There appears to be no evidence to support this claim. subscription. These photos may well be art they're sure as hell not science. Blending New Age mysticism and quantum physics, What The Bleep Do We Know?! Science and engineering are important for our future, and anything that engages the public can only be a good thing." Here's an edited transcript: Cosmic Log: Every once in a while, you'll hear about something like "The Secret," or some other reference to quantum mechanics as explaining how you can change your universe, or even perhaps why it's in the realm of possibility that a globe-gobbling black hole could be created because "anything can happen" in quantum mechanics. Given a few contextual clues, like whether the eyelids are open or shut, it can work out whether it's seeing something or remembering it. Otherwise, the process falls "outside the realm of physical statements and has entered the realm of spiritual belief.". I guess it's a sign that quantum physics is entering the mainstream A: Well, yeah, the point is that there have been these new-age desires for lots of things to make the world better: crystals, energy vortices. Suddenly people who were talking about subatomic particles are alluding to alternate universes and cosmic forces, all of which can be harnessed in the interest of making Ms. Matlin's character feel better about her thighs.